Peter Barca, Democratic representative from Kenosha and Assembly minority leader, siphoned
off some of the scattered complaints from Republican legislators against Gov.
Scott Walker’s proposed state budget, one which claimed that Walker’s support
for more money to private school vouchers would “devastate” public education.
To public sector interests, any move toward competition and individual choice
is “devastating” precisely because public institutions rely on a guaranteed
stream of taxpayer funds, without accountability or innovation.
Another Republican claimed that taxpayers are supporting two education systems. This
argument is disingenuous. The tax revenue for public education flows from one
source, the individual and corporate filings of Wisconsin residents, yet the
individual families which enroll their children choose where the money is spent. Competition
forces schools to cut costs, invest funds effectively, and provide an excellent
education without wasting valuable resources. Besides, Walker’s reforms have
ensured that public school districts can exercise discretion and necessity to
reform health benefits and pension contracts in the future.
Instead of berating Governor
Walker’s proposals in the short term, Assemblymember Barca, and his Democratic
colleagues, should accept his ideas and acquiesce to the accumulating trends of
decentralized and diminished government in the Dairy State. However, Gov. Walker’s
expansion of tax credits is a costly gesture, one which necessitates hiring more
auditors without providing streamlined revenue streams for Wisconsin. Fewer
auditors, fewer tax credits, and lower tax brackets would be better. Tax cuts
for middle class earners, even if two or three dollars a week, is better than
nothing.