Here is the entire essay that I turned in as part of my sentencing.
I have made no edits, since I stand by what I wrote. I will provide a commentary afterwards:
———-
![]("https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-gKk6SE8t35A/XTkZDciYSCI/AAAAAAABlCw/11Hjgy-T5RQ8gljiJUCQtU0Lf_NPH0wwgCLcBGAs/s1600/Museum%2Bof%2BTolerance%2BFront.jpg")
My visit to the Museum of Tolerance was quite eventful. I
had not visited the Museum in decades, so I am glad I could attend again. I
will address specifically each of the sites as directed to attend.
had not visited the Museum in decades, so I am glad I could attend again. I
will address specifically each of the sites as directed to attend.
HEAR AND MEET A HOLOCAUST SURVIVOR
Mrs. Gabriella Karin was born in Slovakia, which at the time
had been part of Czechoslovakia. An expert in pottery and art today, she shares
the pain that she had to deal with when fleeing from Nazis and the Gestapo, and
also the joy that in spite of the great, evil plan to eliminate all Jewry in
Europe failed, and even helped birth the Jewish State of Israel. One early
comment that Mrs. Karin shared was particularly tragic. In 1940, when Nazi
Germany occupied Slovakia, the deportation of Slovak Jews was not undertaken by
Germans, but by fellow Slovaks! It just makes me sick thinking that countrymen
would betray their own.
had been part of Czechoslovakia. An expert in pottery and art today, she shares
the pain that she had to deal with when fleeing from Nazis and the Gestapo, and
also the joy that in spite of the great, evil plan to eliminate all Jewry in
Europe failed, and even helped birth the Jewish State of Israel. One early
comment that Mrs. Karin shared was particularly tragic. In 1940, when Nazi
Germany occupied Slovakia, the deportation of Slovak Jews was not undertaken by
Germans, but by fellow Slovaks! It just makes me sick thinking that countrymen
would betray their own.
Karin shared a number of photos of her childhood. She was a
precious child with a loving family. In fact, two of the most intriguing
aspects of her survival took place in two places, but all in one location, the
capital city of Bratislava. First, she stayed at a Catholic boarding school.
For three years, she stayed with other girls, saved from being separated from
her family. She so missed her mother, however. At one point, her mother did
come to comfort her.
precious child with a loving family. In fact, two of the most intriguing
aspects of her survival took place in two places, but all in one location, the
capital city of Bratislava. First, she stayed at a Catholic boarding school.
For three years, she stayed with other girls, saved from being separated from
her family. She so missed her mother, however. At one point, her mother did
come to comfort her.
From there, Karin stayed in an apartment in another section
of Bratislava. This was a really tense location, in part because across the
street was located the headquarters for the Gestapo in Slovakia. In spite of
such a precarious position, she survived! What made it easier for her to go
unnoticed? The contract for any apartment dweller explicitly stated that no
Jews could live there. Therefore, the Nazis never searched that property!
of Bratislava. This was a really tense location, in part because across the
street was located the headquarters for the Gestapo in Slovakia. In spite of
such a precarious position, she survived! What made it easier for her to go
unnoticed? The contract for any apartment dweller explicitly stated that no
Jews could live there. Therefore, the Nazis never searched that property!
When World War II ended, she married at 17 years old and moved
to Israel. From Israel, she later moved to the United States, specifically Los
Angeles, and she worked as a fashion designer here in the area. Later in life,
she discovered the name of the Slovakia benefactor who had helped her escape
from the Nazi Holocaust. His name was Karol Blanar, and this man had helped
many Jews flee to safety from Nazi-Occupied Slovakia. In a previous talk, Karin
told the audience that she had been trying to find Mr. Blanar, but had been
unsuccessful. An individual in that audience approached her afterwards and
offered to assist in finding this man. Karin found out that Blanar had
immigrated to the United States. He settled in Ohio. Unfortunately, he had already
passed away. His grave maker was unmarked—Karin raised the money to ensure
highest honors for Mr. Blanar!
to Israel. From Israel, she later moved to the United States, specifically Los
Angeles, and she worked as a fashion designer here in the area. Later in life,
she discovered the name of the Slovakia benefactor who had helped her escape
from the Nazi Holocaust. His name was Karol Blanar, and this man had helped
many Jews flee to safety from Nazi-Occupied Slovakia. In a previous talk, Karin
told the audience that she had been trying to find Mr. Blanar, but had been
unsuccessful. An individual in that audience approached her afterwards and
offered to assist in finding this man. Karin found out that Blanar had
immigrated to the United States. He settled in Ohio. Unfortunately, he had already
passed away. His grave maker was unmarked—Karin raised the money to ensure
highest honors for Mr. Blanar!
![]("https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-MTJGSLoGPk8/XTkZKIk9oNI/AAAAAAABlC0/9WdrYvdS2D87pFcVN3FKdxyweeWQx2F3ACLcBGAs/s1600/Museum%2Bof%2BTolerance%2BSurvivor.jpg") |
| Mrs. Gabriella Karin and me |
Mrs. Karin’s account is special because she honored another
Holocaust Survivor, Mr. Bob Geminder from Poland, who fled to the United States
when he was five years old. Sadly, he
had passed away earlier this year. What struck me so much about Mrs. Karin
above all is that she honored other people, men and women who had helped fellow
Jews. It shows great spirit to honor others while recounting the details of
one’s life. I also really appreciated that she recognized the 11 million people
murdered in the Holocaust, not just Jewish communities—which were the most
brutalized.
Holocaust Survivor, Mr. Bob Geminder from Poland, who fled to the United States
when he was five years old. Sadly, he
had passed away earlier this year. What struck me so much about Mrs. Karin
above all is that she honored other people, men and women who had helped fellow
Jews. It shows great spirit to honor others while recounting the details of
one’s life. I also really appreciated that she recognized the 11 million people
murdered in the Holocaust, not just Jewish communities—which were the most
brutalized.
PARA TODOS LOS NINOS/FOR ALL THE CHILDREN
Along this wall of the higher echelons of the museum, I
learned more about the Westminster v. Mendez case, specifically
presented by documentarian Sandra Robbie in her film “For All the Children.”
The testimonies from Latino activists during and after that celebrated court
case were interesting to learn about.
learned more about the Westminster v. Mendez case, specifically
presented by documentarian Sandra Robbie in her film “For All the Children.”
The testimonies from Latino activists during and after that celebrated court
case were interesting to learn about.
While most people who read history know about Brown v.
Board of Education, which struck down the so-called “separate but equal”
doctrine which had permitted segregated facilities, especially in education.
Board of Education, which struck down the so-called “separate but equal”
doctrine which had permitted segregated facilities, especially in education.
Mrs. Robbie’s quote says it all: "So many of us believe
that the fight for Civil Rights is a black and white battle … Mendez v.
Westminster is the story of people of many colors fighting for American
equality right here in Orange County.”
that the fight for Civil Rights is a black and white battle … Mendez v.
Westminster is the story of people of many colors fighting for American
equality right here in Orange County.”
This exhibit I found to be the most disappointing. The fight
for the rights of all children, including Hispanic students, should have gotten
more attention than this one-wall exhibit had provided. Most Californians have
no idea that activists for civil rights helped lead the fight for equal
education opportunities for all—and pretty much right in our backyard! Some of
the posters and signs along the exhibit point out, sadly, that publication
education today has not lived up to the expectations outlined in the Westminster
case.
for the rights of all children, including Hispanic students, should have gotten
more attention than this one-wall exhibit had provided. Most Californians have
no idea that activists for civil rights helped lead the fight for equal
education opportunities for all—and pretty much right in our backyard! Some of
the posters and signs along the exhibit point out, sadly, that publication
education today has not lived up to the expectations outlined in the Westminster
case.
FINDING OUR FAMILIES, FINDING OURSELVES
This was a new and lively exhibit! The narration of different
actors and celebrities, including Maya Angelou, as well as Billy Crystal and
Carlos Santana, was quite engaging. The story of our forefathers coming from
different countries to see the world is a story that all of us should learn. I
never realized that Comedian Billy Crystal’s father was into boxing, for
example. I learned a little about Crystal’s brother.
actors and celebrities, including Maya Angelou, as well as Billy Crystal and
Carlos Santana, was quite engaging. The story of our forefathers coming from
different countries to see the world is a story that all of us should learn. I
never realized that Comedian Billy Crystal’s father was into boxing, for
example. I learned a little about Crystal’s brother.
One of the exhibit featured the long, arduous, and even
invasive process that immigrants had to undergone to enter the United States.
The walls had pictured the different doors, exam rooms, etc. which
newly-arriving immigrants would go into. The health exams which individual were
required to undergo should give us all pause and also a sense of gratitude. Our
forefathers endured so much so that we would not have to.
invasive process that immigrants had to undergone to enter the United States.
The walls had pictured the different doors, exam rooms, etc. which
newly-arriving immigrants would go into. The health exams which individual were
required to undergo should give us all pause and also a sense of gratitude. Our
forefathers endured so much so that we would not have to.
The different stories I learned about, the families who
braved many setbacks to come to the United States, reminds me that we need to
respect those individuals who play by the rules, pay all the fees, pass all the
tests to become American citizens, and we should not permit anyone to diminish
the process and the people who followed those processes to make the United
States a wonderful place.
braved many setbacks to come to the United States, reminds me that we need to
respect those individuals who play by the rules, pay all the fees, pass all the
tests to become American citizens, and we should not permit anyone to diminish
the process and the people who followed those processes to make the United
States a wonderful place.
The section of the exhibit which featured scenes from Maya
Angelou’s novel I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings was a strange
transition. Angelou’s account of growing up in TexArkana seemed a little out of
place at first, but when the narration of her life, in poetry and prose, came
through the loudspeakers, I finally understand how Maya had so much to learn
about her parents—her grandparents’—past and the character of their lives
growing up in the Old South.
Angelou’s novel I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings was a strange
transition. Angelou’s account of growing up in TexArkana seemed a little out of
place at first, but when the narration of her life, in poetry and prose, came
through the loudspeakers, I finally understand how Maya had so much to learn
about her parents—her grandparents’—past and the character of their lives
growing up in the Old South.
![]("https://1.bp.blogspot.com/-1fyYyY5mrEQ/XTkZmPy6XfI/AAAAAAABlDA/-q0a0UFtJb4Bny2Uattlw8FtcBGqgJA_wCLcBGAs/s1600/Museum%2Bof%2BTolerance%2BFlag.jpg")
TOLERANCE CENTER
This site was updated considerably from what I had seen from
my second year in college. New TV monitors along the walls indicated how diverse
the news, the media, and its effects on public opinion have become.
my second year in college. New TV monitors along the walls indicated how diverse
the news, the media, and its effects on public opinion have become.
I remembered the two doors, one read “Prejudiced”, the other
“Unprejudiced.” This time, however, if anyone approached the “Unprejudiced”, a
sign “think twice before trying” appeared on the door. As all of us should.
“Unprejudiced.” This time, however, if anyone approached the “Unprejudiced”, a
sign “think twice before trying” appeared on the door. As all of us should.
There was the “Free Speech” exhibit, which included
interacting with a scenario and responding to different questions. At this
stage of my life, I believe that free speech must be protected all the more,
including speech we do not like or find offensive. The scenario which suggested
that heated rhetoric from a radio station would so inflame the passions.
interacting with a scenario and responding to different questions. At this
stage of my life, I believe that free speech must be protected all the more,
including speech we do not like or find offensive. The scenario which suggested
that heated rhetoric from a radio station would so inflame the passions.
The maps detailing different hate groups, as well as the
escalation of divisive hatred based on race, brought home to me how important
it is for us to fight lies with truth, fear with facts.
escalation of divisive hatred based on race, brought home to me how important
it is for us to fight lies with truth, fear with facts.
THE “HOLOCAUST” SECTION
I never cried at a Museum before. This is the first time I
walked out of an exhibit and wept. It’s really horrifying to me that so many
people are questioning whether the Holocaust happened. The dramatizations of
different Germans sitting at a café was quite informative. I appreciate that
the exhibit drew from primary sources to share the accounts from actual
individuals concerned about the Nazi Reich.
walked out of an exhibit and wept. It’s really horrifying to me that so many
people are questioning whether the Holocaust happened. The dramatizations of
different Germans sitting at a café was quite informative. I appreciate that
the exhibit drew from primary sources to share the accounts from actual
individuals concerned about the Nazi Reich.
History doesn’t really impact people unless they have a
tactile experience in some fashion. Seeing the letters about Hitler’s plans to
eliminate all Jewry, watching the dramatizations of Nazi leaders looking for a
more efficient means for destroying every Jewish person in Eastern Europe and
throughout the continent, were quite harrowing.
tactile experience in some fashion. Seeing the letters about Hitler’s plans to
eliminate all Jewry, watching the dramatizations of Nazi leaders looking for a
more efficient means for destroying every Jewish person in Eastern Europe and
throughout the continent, were quite harrowing.
I had forgotten that members of the public who visit this
section will walk through sections labeled “Able-Bodied” vs. “Women and
Children.” One station in the exhibit focused on the fact that a number of
Jewish refugees arrived by ocean liner—and were all turned back! Terrible.
Countries need to take care of their own people, but at what people does a
nation’s leadership need to take into account that some crises are too great to
ignore, and that those refugees need assistance?
section will walk through sections labeled “Able-Bodied” vs. “Women and
Children.” One station in the exhibit focused on the fact that a number of
Jewish refugees arrived by ocean liner—and were all turned back! Terrible.
Countries need to take care of their own people, but at what people does a
nation’s leadership need to take into account that some crises are too great to
ignore, and that those refugees need assistance?
The scenes of dead bodies dumped into mass graves was really
sickening. In contrast, the account of one Jewish Rabbi who stood up to one of
the Nazi officers in a death camp was inspiring: “You will never destroy the
Jewish people. All race will live forever,” this rabbi declared. Onlookers who
survived that death camp would remark how impressive that Rabbi’s courage was
before he and others were forced to march into the gas chambers.
sickening. In contrast, the account of one Jewish Rabbi who stood up to one of
the Nazi officers in a death camp was inspiring: “You will never destroy the
Jewish people. All race will live forever,” this rabbi declared. Onlookers who
survived that death camp would remark how impressive that Rabbi’s courage was
before he and others were forced to march into the gas chambers.
SUMMARY
It pains me that I have met more young people who have not
heard of the Holocaust. That’s a calamity which must be averted at all costs.
“Hope lives when people remember”—Simon Weisenthal.
heard of the Holocaust. That’s a calamity which must be averted at all costs.
“Hope lives when people remember”—Simon Weisenthal.
I do believe that this country needs a more robust
discussion on freedom of speech—the problem in Nazi Germany was not only the
hateful invective of the Reich and Hitler’s regime, but that opposing parties
and independent journalists were silenced. Let’s maintain this right for all to
stop hate!
discussion on freedom of speech—the problem in Nazi Germany was not only the
hateful invective of the Reich and Hitler’s regime, but that opposing parties
and independent journalists were silenced. Let’s maintain this right for all to
stop hate!
———
Some things that I did not include in the report which I turned into the court:
1. The Simon Wiesenthal center seems to be losing its focus. There is all this talk about immigration and identity politics, and I fear that much of this obscures the much larger focus of maintaining a livingm working memory of the Holocaust. A growing number of students leave high school in California and across the country–and they know nothing about the decimation of 11 million people, including 6 million Jews and 5 million other so-called "undesirables" at the hands of the Nazi Reich.
2. I am really glad that I included my remarks about freedom of speech. The truth is that Hitler and his hateful Nazis could utter whatever bile they wanted. The problem was that the common people, the activists, the concerned citizens were not permitted to criticism. The answer to speech is more speech. Freedom of speech gives power to the truth to overcome the lies.
Silencing, suppressing speech because it is deemed hateful actually allows hateful speech–and hateful acts–to proliferate. That is exactly what happened during the Third Reich. Right now, sadly too many people are learning the wrong lessons, and they are foolishly concluding that the only way to prevent "hate speech" is to silence speech. That is a form of hate in itself which will protect no one.
3. I would like a broader discussion as to why so many kids are leaving public schools throughout Los Angeles Unified and the greater California system with no knowledge of the Holocaust and other heinous genocides perpetrated throughout the 20th Century. Is it true that no one will care about the Armenians? Is it true that no one will remember the Rwandans, too?
4. When I entered the Museum of Tolerance, I was really surprised that a security guard not only greeted us in the parking lot, but required every guest to have their trunk inspected! The security concerns have grown in and around the facility!
5. During the Holocaust survivor's talk, some members of the audience seemed determined to blame President Trump for the climate of extremism and hate fostered around the country. I commend Mrs. Karin for refusing to take the bait and simply focusing on the historical facts, the historical tragedy, of what she lived through, and yet so few survived.
6. The theme of "Ordinary People" came back to me again in the History Walk-Through on the Holocaust, from Hitler's rise to power to the Allied Victories in Europe. "Ordinary people" did nothing to stop the tide of Hitler's tyranny, but ordinary people also stepped up to stand up to the evils that were engulfing Europe in the early 1940s.
The banality of evil does not diminish the evil, but merely reveals that no matter how much man may pride himself, he is a fallen creature in need of redemption.